Geeking Out’s Kerri Doherty and My Damn Channel’s Mark Malkoff camped out on the sidewalk outside Silvercup Studios last month in Long Island City. They had a mission: High-five the cast of NBC’s 30 Rock, which tapes at Silvercup.

Time was running out.

30 Rock wrapped its final season on NBC. Could Doherty and Malkoff high-five the cast as they left the studio? Spoiler alert: It didn’t really happen like that. How did it go down? Did their hands meet the hands of Tina Fey? Tracy Morgan? Grizz? Lutz? Roll the clip!